USMNT World Cup failure: United States soccer had this coming
1. Americans don’t know how to develop soccer talent
Americans fundamentally don’t understand how to play soccer and especially don’t know how to develop talent. The current model makes it difficult for young athletes to excel in a professional environment.
While European nations are developing their best athletes from the get-go, Americans oftentimes wait until their players are in high school to seriously begin developing their talent. By that point, too many promising players have slipped through the cracks and others simply don’t have enough time to develop.
High schoolers don’t play year-round, the way European prospects do. A lack of high-level academies means players need to pay for expensive clubs or they play for high school coaches who have no business being high school soccer coaches, then end up playing college soccer, which is not the developmental league that college sports are for the NFL and NBA.
Even when good players are developed in the MLS academies, they usually never make it out of MLS, where the players mire in mediocrity
Soccer is played by more than enough kids to give the US a talent base. The “our best athletes don’t play soccer” argument isn’t a good one. The United States has had decades to develop World Cup-class talent, but they are yet to do so. Plenty of athletes play soccer, they just aren’t being taught how.